Wire Fraud in Utah Home Sales: How It Happens and How to Avoid It
How real estate wire fraud works, why closing week is when it happens, what Utah buyers and sellers can do to protect their money, and what to do in the first hours if money goes to the wrong account.

A few days before closing, you get an email from the title company. Same logo, same signature, the name of the escrow officer you've been working with. It says the wiring instructions have changed and gives you a new account. You send your down payment.
Nothing about that email looked wrong, and the money is gone.
This is real estate wire fraud. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center received 12,368 real estate fraud complaints in 2025, with $275 million in reported losses, up from about $173 million the year before. In Utah, 298 people lost a combined $25.5 million to email-based scams in 2025, a category that includes real estate wire fraud.
The good news is that this kind of fraud is preventable, and the habit that prevents it takes about five minutes.
How it works
The scam usually starts weeks earlier and somewhere else. Someone involved in the transaction, often an agent, a loan officer or an employee at a title company, clicks a link in a convincing email and gives up their password. The criminal doesn't do anything noticeable. They read the inbox and wait.
When a closing date gets close, they know the names, the address, the amount and the schedule. Then they send an email that looks exactly like the real thing, either from the compromised account itself or from an address that differs by a single letter. The message gives "updated" wiring instructions, sometimes with a reason (an audit, a new bank, a problem with the old account) and often with some urgency.
Buyers are the usual target because they wire the largest amount, but sellers aren't immune. A seller can receive a fake request to send their proceeds somewhere new, and a payoff or earnest money transfer can be redirected the same way.
Once a wire lands in the criminal's account, it's usually moved out within hours. Unlike a card payment, a wire can't simply be disputed and reversed.
Why it's so convincing
People who lose money this way aren't careless. The email arrives at exactly the moment they're expecting one, from a person they've already been emailing, about an amount they already know. Nothing seems out of place because the criminal has been reading the real conversation.
That's why the advice isn't "look for spelling mistakes." A good fraud email won't have any. The only reliable protection is to confirm the instructions through a channel the criminal doesn't control.
How to protect yourself
Get the title company's phone number early, and from a source you trust. At the start of the transaction, look up the title company's number yourself, on its official website or from a printed document you received in person. Don't use a number from an email signature, because that's exactly what a criminal can change.
Call before every wire. Before you send any money, call that number and confirm the account number and routing number by voice, with a person at the title company. It takes a few minutes, and it's the single step that stops nearly all of these scams. The Utah Division of Real Estate gives the same advice: verify any change by calling over phone numbers you already established.
Treat any change in instructions as a red flag. Title companies rarely change wiring instructions in the middle of a transaction. If you're told the account has changed, stop and call before doing anything else.
Confirm the money arrived. After the wire goes out, call the title company again and confirm they received it. If something went wrong, you want to know within hours, not days.
Don't email account numbers or send sensitive documents over plain email if your title company offers a secure portal. Many do.
Sellers, apply the same rules to your proceeds. If you're asked to change where your money is sent, confirm it by phone at a number you already trust before agreeing.
If you're buying without an agent, our guide to buying a home in Utah without your own agent covers who works for whom.
If money goes to the wrong account
Speed matters more than anything else. If you think you've wired money to a criminal:
- Call your bank immediately and tell them you were the victim of wire fraud. Ask them to recall the wire and to contact the receiving bank. Do this before anything else.
- Report it to the FBI at ic3.gov. Reports filed quickly give law enforcement the best chance of freezing the money before it moves.
- Call the title company, using the number you know is real, so they can alert everyone involved and check whether other accounts were compromised.
- Call your local police department and keep a record of every email, phone number and transaction detail.
Recovering money is never guaranteed, but the odds are much better in the first hours than after a few days.
What's changing in Utah
Utah has warned about this scam for years. The Division of Real Estate has warned about this since at least 2016. Utah law requires title insurance agencies to report to the state insurance commissioner when they reasonably believe a wire they sent, or were supposed to receive, didn't arrive within two business days. In September 2026, Rep. Jake Sawyer said he is drafting legislation for the 2027 session that would require extra verification, including a confirmation code sent to the borrower, before a homebuyer's money is wired.
Until rules like that are in place, the protection is the same as it has always been: pick up the phone.
A note on how Aletheia handles this
Aletheia never asks you to send money through the platform and never sends wiring instructions. Your earnest money and closing funds go to the title company named in your contract. If the other party in your sale isn't using Aletheia, share this guide with them too.
Figures are from the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center, as reported by NAR and HousingWire, and FBI data reported by KUTV. This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.
General information, not legal advice. For advice about your situation, talk to a Utah real estate attorney.
Ready to try it yourself?
Aletheia gives buyers and sellers a clearer way to handle offers. See how it works or create a free account.


